{"id":"UFO115-INC-1948-001","name":"The Aztec UFO Incident — 1948","editorialTitle":"WHAT DID THEY FIND?","date":"1948-03-01","datePrecision":"month","location":{"place":"Hart Canyon, about 12 miles northeast of Aztec, New Mexico","region":"North America","country":"United States","lat":36.9,"lng":-107.9},"categories":["crash","crash_retrieval","historical","government"],"classification":"disputed","summary":"According to Frank Scully, an unidentified craft carrying sixteen humanoid bodies made a controlled landing in Hart Canyon, New Mexico, in March 1948 and was recovered by the military . The story reached the public through Scully's 1949 Variety columns and his 1950 book Behind the Flying Saucers, based on what two men told him . In 1952 the story was exposed as a hoax made up by two con men as part of a scheme to sell materials said to contain extraterrestrial technology, and the two men were convicted of fraud in 1953 . Some ufologists say a one-page 1950 FBI memo backs up the crash, but the FBI called it a second- or third-hand claim it never investigated .","url":"https://ufo115.com/evidence-timeline/incidents/aztec-1948","lastReviewed":"2026-11-15","version":1,"alternateNames":["Aztec crashed saucer hoax","The other Roswell"],"caseFeatures":{},"claims":[{"text":"Newton and Gebauer were convicted of fraud in 1953 over a scheme to sell materials said to incorporate extraterrestrial technology.","type":"documented","sources":[1,2,3]},{"text":"A metal sample given to J. P. Cahn by Newton and Gebauer turned out to be ordinary aluminium.","type":"documented","sources":[1,2,3]},{"text":"The FBI stated in 2013 that the Hottel memo does not prove the existence of UFOs and is a second- or third-hand claim it never investigated.","type":"official","sources":[1]},{"text":"The Air Force said there is no Hangar 18 at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base and noted that Robert Spencer Carr's 1974 claims mirrored the plot of a novel.","type":"official","sources":[1]},{"text":"Scully's account said a 99-foot craft carrying sixteen humanoid bodies landed in Hart Canyon in March 1948 and was taken by the military.","type":"alleged","sources":[1]},{"text":"The Aztec county sheriff and newspaper editor of March 1948, the sheriff's son and the landowning family all denied that a retrieval took place.","type":"witness","sources":[1]},{"text":"The Ramseys and Frank Thayer argue the crash was real and that the government engineered the case against Newton and Gebauer to sink Aztec.","type":"disputed","sources":[1,4]},{"text":"The Hottel memo may relate to Aztec, but it never names the town and the original source of the informant's account is unknown.","type":"disputed","sources":[1,4]},{"text":"In 1974 ufologist Robert Spencer Carr claimed that alien bodies recovered near Aztec were stored at a Wright-Patterson building called Hangar 18.","type":"alleged","sources":[1]}],"chronology":[{"when":"March 1948","text":"The date given in the Scully account for the alleged landing in Hart Canyon, 12 miles northeast of Aztec [1].","sources":[1]},{"when":"1949","text":"Frank Scully publishes the story in a series of Variety columns [1].","sources":[1]},{"when":"January 1950","text":"The Wyandotte Echo prints a version of the story that was traced thirdhand to Newton [1][3].","sources":[1,3]},{"when":"22 March 1950","text":"FBI agent Guy Hottel writes the one-page memo relaying a third party's account of recovered craft [1][4].","sources":[1,4]},{"when":"1950","text":"Scully's book Behind the Flying Saucers is published [1].","sources":[1]},{"when":"1952","text":"J. P. Cahn exposes the hoax in True magazine [1][2].","sources":[1,2]},{"when":"1953","text":"Newton and Gebauer are convicted of fraud [1][2].","sources":[1,2]},{"when":"1974","text":"Robert Spencer Carr claims Aztec bodies are stored at Hangar 18; the Air Force denies it [1].","sources":[1]},{"when":"1986","text":"William Steinman and Wendelle Stevens publish UFO Crash at Aztec [2][3].","sources":[2,3]},{"when":"August 2022","text":"The Black Vault obtains an unredacted Hottel memo naming the informant as Karl Howe [1].","sources":[1]}],"sources":[{"n":1,"title":"Aztec crashed saucer hoax","publisher":"Wikipedia","published":"read 2026-11-15","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aztec_crashed_saucer_hoax","checked":"2026-11-15"},{"n":2,"title":"Aztec (New Mexico) UFO Hoax - The Skeptic's Dictionary","publisher":"skepdic.com","published":"read 2026-11-15","url":"http://skepdic.com/aztec.html","checked":"2026-11-15"},{"n":3,"title":"FBI Hottel Memo Reveals UFO Hoax","publisher":"ibtimes.com","published":"read 2026-11-15","url":"http://www.ibtimes.com/fbi-hottel-memo-reveals-ufo-hoax-279533","checked":"2026-11-15"},{"n":4,"title":"Uncovering The Aztec UFO Incident","publisher":"DGO Magazine","published":"2023-06-01","url":"https://dgomag.com/uncovering-the-aztec-ufo-incident/","checked":"2026-11-15"}]}