Early on 3 September 1965, 18-year-old Norman Muscarello reported flashing red lights hovering over a field in Kensington, New Hampshire, and two Exeter police officers said they saw the object too [1]. The Air Force sent officers from Pease Air Force Base, and the Pentagon and Project Blue Book then offered explanations that the witnesses rejected [1]. In January 1966 an Air Force reply to the officers said the object had not been identified [1]. A 2011 Skeptical Inquirer article proposed that the lights came from a KC-97 tanker aircraft, and some supporters of the case dispute that [1][2].
WHAT KIND OF CLAIM IS THIS?
- 1 DOCUMENTEDEstablished by records or contemporary reporting.
- 3 OFFICIALWhat an official body stated or concluded.
- 2 WITNESSWhat a witness reported. Not independently established.
- 1 DISPUTEDContested between sources.
- 1 ALLEGEDA claim made later, unsupported by the record.
- DOCUMENTED Muscarello, Bertrand and Hunt each filed a separate report with Exeter police after the encounter. [1]
- OFFICIAL Major David Griffin wrote to Project Blue Book that he could not find a probable cause and judged the three observers stable and reliable. [1]
- OFFICIAL The Pentagon told reporters that the three men had seen nothing more than stars and planets twinkling because of a temperature inversion. [1]
- OFFICIAL In January 1966 an Air Force reply to the two officers said the Air Force had been unable to identify the object. [1]
- WITNESS Muscarello said the lights were pulsating, silent and so bright that he could not make out a silhouette, and that he heard horses kicking the barn nearby. [3]
- WITNESS Bertrand and Hunt said the object was silent, had no wings or tail and lit up the whole field, and that the weather ruled out an inversion. [1]
- DISPUTED Nickell and McGaha proposed that the five red lights were those of a KC-97 tanker, a view Kathleen Marden rejects. [1][2]
- ALLEGED Dean Merchant says that Congressional hearings in 1966 saw the Air Force admit it could not solve the case and apologise to the officers; the other sources here do not corroborate this. [2]
WHAT HAPPENED
At about 2:00 a.m. on 3 September 1965, 18-year-old Norman Muscarello was hitchhiking home to Exeter along New Hampshire Route 150 when, near Kensington, he noticed five flashing bright red lights in the distance [1]. He reported that they hovered just above the trees, lit a nearby field and two houses in red light, and moved towards him without a sound, so that he threw himself into a ditch [1]. He then ran to a house and banged on the door without being answered, and he stopped a passing car, whose occupants drove him to the Exeter police station [1].
At the station he told his story to officer Reginald Toland, who radioed patrolman Eugene Bertrand Jr. [1]. Bertrand drove Muscarello back to the field. According to the account in Wikipedia, horses in a corral became frightened and dogs barked, and the two men then saw an object rise from the trees beyond the corral [1]. Bertrand described it as "this huge, dark object as big as a barn over there, with red flashing lights on it" [1]. He radioed for David Hunt, who arrived a few minutes later and also watched it [1]. The object then rose over the trees and disappeared [1]. The three men returned to the police station and filed separate reports [1].
Muscarello, Bertrand and Hunt each filed a separate report with Exeter police after the encounter.
BACKGROUND
The Exeter area had already produced several separate sighting reports in the weeks before 3 September, but this was the one that became by far the most famous [1]. Muscarello had graduated from high school the previous June, was about three weeks from leaving for service in the United States Navy, and had recently sold his car, which is why he was walking and hitchhiking home from his girlfriend's parents' home in Amesbury, Massachusetts [1]. Pease Air Force Base lay nearby, and the Air Force later said it had five B-47 aircraft flying in the area that night [1].
Other reports reached the police that night. Muscarello later recalled that Toland told him reports had already come in from Raymond and from Hampton Beach, and he described a call from a man in a phone booth who was gone by the time police arrived, leaving the phone dangling [3]. Bertrand had earlier spoken to a frightened woman in her car who said a large object with flashing red lights had followed her from Epping [1]. The sources disagree on where he met her: one gives Route 108 and another the Route 101 bypass [1][2]. The writer John G. Fuller learned of the case through the National Investigations Committee on Aerial Phenomena and went on to write about it in magazines and then in the 1966 book Incident at Exeter [2].
CHRONOLOGY
Several separate sightings are reported in the Exeter area. [1]
Muscarello reports flashing red lights over a field near Kensington while hitchhiking on Route 150. [1]
According to Fuller's account as retold by New Hampshire Magazine, Muscarello arrives at the Exeter police station. [2]
Bertrand takes Muscarello back to the field, they see the object, and Hunt arrives and also watches it. [1]
Major David Griffin and Lieutenant Alan Brandt of Pease Air Force Base interview the three men. [1]
The Pentagon and Project Blue Book offer explanations, which the officers dispute. [1]
Bertrand and Hunt send a second letter to Project Blue Book. [1]
Lt Col John Spaulding replies that the Air Force has been unable to identify the object. [1]
Joe Nickell and James McGaha propose the KC-97 tanker explanation in Skeptical Inquirer. [1][2]
WITNESS ACCOUNTS
Muscarello gave his own account to Exeter High School students in 1980 [3]. He said it was a clear night, that he heard horses raising a commotion and that the crickets seemed to stop, and that the lights were pulsating and very bright, with no silhouette he could make out [3]. He said he had gone to the police station because he thought he was cracking up, and that he was glad other people had seen it [3]. He insisted for the rest of his life that what he saw was real and not an ordinary object [1].
Bertrand and Hunt gave their own descriptions. In a letter to Project Blue Book, the two officers said they saw the object at close range, checked it with each other, and were sure it was not a conventional aircraft [1]. They later wrote that it was absolutely silent, had no wings or tail, and lit up the entire field so that two nearby houses turned red [1]. Hunt soon heard a B-47 bomber fly overhead, and he later told Fuller there was no comparison between the bomber and the object [1].
The wider area also produced reports. Fuller interviewed a number of people in the area who said they had also seen strange lights and unusual objects, and Toland told him of other calls from residents [1]. Raymond Fowler of NICAP, who filed an 18-page report, said both officers seemed intelligent and capable and that Bertrand's Air Force refuelling experience made him able to tell a UFO from other aircraft [2].

#NOMORESECRETS
WEAR THE STORY.
Lights Over the Desert 1997 Poster
Lights Over the Desert 1997 Tee
Government Denial Is Futile Poster
Sky Watcher Ring of Fire Tee
WHAT THE INVESTIGATIONS FOUND
After Exeter's police chief read the three reports, he called Pease Air Force Base, which sent Major David Griffin and Lieutenant Alan Brandt to interview the men [1]. Griffin's report to Major Hector Quintanilla of Project Blue Book said he could not arrive at a probable cause, that the observers seemed stable and reliable, especially the two patrolmen, and that he found nothing in the area that could explain it [1]. He did not think the five B-47s were connected [1].
Before Project Blue Book could send that evaluation to the Pentagon, an explanation had already been given to the press [1]. The Pentagon told reporters the three men had seen nothing more than stars and planets twinkling because of a temperature inversion [1]. Blue Book then said Operation Big Blast, a SAC/NORAD training mission, had been active that night and could have accounted for the sighting [1]. Quintanilla wrote to Bertrand and Hunt that the objects might be associated with that operation, while adding that it would be eliminated if the officers had noticed the aircraft [1].
The officers replied that they had been ridiculed, that the weather was clear with no wind and no chance of an inversion, and that the sighting came nearly an hour after Big Blast was said to have ended [1]. In January 1966 Lieutenant Colonel John Spaulding of the Office of the Secretary of the Air Force wrote that, based on additional information, the Air Force had been unable to identify the object [1].
EXPLANATIONS
The early official explanations were stars and planets seen through a temperature inversion, and then aircraft taking part in Operation Big Blast [1]. The witnesses rejected both, and the Air Force's own January 1966 reply said the object could not be identified [1]. Fowler also described an Air Force officer who tried to show a crowd that the lights were from Pease by having the base lights switched on; he said nothing appeared to change, and the officer left to jeers [1].
A later proposal came in 2011 from the sceptic Joe Nickell and James McGaha, a retired Air Force major and pilot, in Skeptical Inquirer [1][2]. McGaha said he recognised the reported sequence of five red lights as the pattern on the underside of KC-97 tanker aircraft like those stationed at Pease, and that the refuelling boom could flutter in the air, which would fit Muscarello's description of floating like a leaf [1]. The two sources differ on the boom's angle, giving 60 degrees in one and 64 degrees, quoted from a flight manual, in the other [1][2]. They also suggested that the brightness of the lights would make other features of the object indistinguishable from the ground [2].
This proposal is a hypothesis put forward by the authors; the sources do not record any confirmation that a tanker was in the area [1][2]. Kathleen Marden, niece of Betty Hill, rejected it, saying the explanation does not fit the evidence [2].
WHAT REMAINS DISPUTED
The central question is unresolved: no source here establishes what the object was. Marden calls it a credible close-range sighting, while Nickell and McGaha propose a tanker aircraft [2]. The Air Force's last word in the sources is that it could not identify the object [1]. Ryan Mullahy, founder of New Hampshire UFO Research, was scheduled to argue at the 2015 Exeter UFO Festival that "Exeter Remains Unsolved" [2].
Some details are contested. Muscarello said that at his mother's house at daybreak that same morning an Air Force major named Kehoe and a sergeant with a handcuffed attaché case told him not to sign anything [3]. His brother Thomas said he did not remember that, though he did recall a stern officer from Pease visiting the house and questioning their mother, and the article says Norman was in Michigan at the time [4]. The two accounts of when and where this happened do not match, and the sources do not settle it.
Dean Merchant, co-founder of the Exeter UFO Festival, said Congressional hearings in 1966 saw the Air Force admit it could not solve the case and apologise to the two officers [2]. That is his account, and none of the other sources here mentions the hearings or an apology. Merchant also has his own theory that UFOs "seem to be very curious about our use of nuclear things" in the area [2].
QUESTIONS PEOPLE ASK
What did Norman Muscarello report?
He reported five flashing red lights hovering above trees near Kensington, which lit a field and two houses red, moved towards him silently and made him dive into a ditch [1].
Did police officers see it too?
Patrolmen Eugene Bertrand Jr. and David Hunt said they saw it, with Bertrand describing a huge dark object with red flashing lights, and they and Muscarello filed separate reports that night [1].
What did the Air Force say it was?
The Pentagon first said stars and planets seen through a temperature inversion, and Blue Book then pointed to Operation Big Blast [1]. In January 1966 an Air Force reply said the object could not be identified [1].
THE RECONSTRUCTION

A dark field and treeline under a clear sky, with five red lights hanging above the trees and tinting a nearby house. It shows what the witnesses reported, not what was there.
AI-generated artistic reconstruction. UFO115 dramatization, not evidence and not a photograph of the event. Hero image source: UFO115 reconstruction (local AI model, 2026).
SOURCES
- Exeter incident. Wikipedia, read 2026-11-15. Read 2026-11-15. Link checked 2026-11-15 (HTTP 200).
- New Hampshire's UFO History and the Exeter UFO Festival. New Hampshire Magazine, 2015-08-12. Read 2026-11-15. Link checked 2026-11-15 (HTTP 200).
- Norman Muscarello Recalls His UFO Incident at Exeter. SeacoastNH.com, 1980 interview, published online 2000. Read 2026-11-15. Link checked 2026-11-15 (HTTP 200).
- Exeter's UFO kid dead at 55. Seacoastonline, 2003-03-02. Read 2026-11-15. Link checked 2026-11-15 (HTTP 200).
CITE THIS RECORD
UFO115. "The Exeter Incident — 1965." UFO115 Evidence Timeline, record UFO115-INC-1965-002, version 1. Last reviewed 2026-11-15. https://ufo115.com/evidence-timeline/incidents/exeter-1965
APA: UFO115. (2026). The Exeter Incident — 1965 (Record UFO115-INC-1965-002, v1). UFO115 Evidence Timeline. https://ufo115.com/evidence-timeline/incidents/exeter-1965
MLA: "The Exeter Incident — 1965." UFO115 Evidence Timeline, UFO115, 2026-11-15, https://ufo115.com/evidence-timeline/incidents/exeter-1965.
Last reviewed by The UFO115 desk. Record UFO115-INC-1965-002, version 1. Machine-readable record.
“THE UNKNOWN ARRIVED” is UFO115's editorial framing, not a claim that events happened as dramatized.