UFO115.COM
Real UFO photos: the documented cases, and what they turned out to be
Seven of the most famous UFO photographs and videos with real provenance: McMinnville 1950, Lubbock 1951, Washington 1952, Petit-Rechain 1990 and the Navy FLIR, GIMBAL and GOFAST videos. Who took them, where they are held, and what investigators concluded. Fact and claim labelled apart.
Last updated
By The UFO115 desk, UFO115 · Published
Everybody has seen these pictures. Fewer people know who took them, where the originals went, or what happened when investigators got hold of them. Here are seven with a real paper trail, fact first, claims after. No images are reproduced here; each case links to whoever holds the original or the official record.
On the record
1. McMinnville, Oregon, 1950: the Trent photos
Who and when. Paul and Evelyn Trent took two photographs on their farm near McMinnville, Oregon, in 1950; the Condon Report dates the sighting to 11 May 1950.[1][2] A local reporter, Bill Powell, borrowed the negatives and ran the photos on the front page of the McMinnville Telephone-Register on 8 June 1950; Life printed cropped versions on 26 June 1950 and then told the Trents it had misplaced the negatives.[2]
Where the originals went. The negatives turned up in 1967 in the files of United Press International, were lent to the astronomer William K. Hartmann for the University of Colorado's Air Force-funded UFO study, and were returned to UPI, which in 1970 sent them to the editor of the News-Register; in 1975 the ufologist Bruce Maccabee studied negatives from that paper's files.[2] The case and its photo plates were published as Case 46 of the Condon Report, which is the public record to read: Condon Report, Case 46.[1]
What the investigation concluded. Hartmann's photometry put the object at roughly 1.3 km away. He wrote that this was "one of the few UFO reports in which all factors investigated, geometric, psychological, and physical appear to be consistent with" the witnesses' account, and in the same conclusion that "It cannot be said that the evidence positively rules out a fabrication."[1] He flagged the weak point himself: the object sits beneath roughly the same point of an overhead wire in both photos, which "can be used as an argument favoring a suspended model."[1] Verdict: unresolved.
2. Lubbock, Texas, 1951: the Hart photos
Who and when. On the night of 25 August 1951, a group of professors from Texas Technological College reported formations of soft, glowing lights passing over Lubbock, and saw more on later nights. Ruppelt's account dates Carl Hart, Jr.'s photographs to the night of 31 August: Hart, a Texas Tech freshman, photographed a formation of lights from the back yard of his family's home.[3]
Where the originals went. Hart lent his negatives to the Air Force: there had been five, but he could only produce four.[3] Ruppelt took them to the Photo Reconnaissance Laboratory at Wright Field.[3] Project Blue Book's records were later retired to the National Archives, which holds the case files on microfilm and says photographs among them were filmed separately on the last two rolls: National Archives, Project BLUE BOOK.[4]
What the investigation concluded. The lab found an inverted V of near-pinpoint lights, blurred by camera motion, and no stars in the background, so the lights were far brighter than the stars, or affected the film more.[3] The professors said the photos did not match what they saw: they had reported soft lights in an unorderly group, Hart a bright, perfect formation.[3] Ruppelt's official conclusion: "The photos were never proven to be a hoax but neither were they proven to be genuine."[3]
3. Washington, DC, 1952: the radar case nobody photographed
Who and when. The Washington sightings are remembered as pictures, but the evidence was radar and eyewitnesses. On the night of 19 July 1952 air traffic controller Edward Nugent at Washington National Airport picked up seven objects on radar; his superior, Harry Barnes, watched them too, and more targets followed over consecutive weekends, 18-19 and 26-27 July.[5] When the radar room filled again on 26 July, reporters and photographers were asked to leave before jet interceptors were vectored in.[3]
Where the record is. The case sits in Blue Book's files; Ruppelt called it one of "the most monumentally fouled-up messes that repose in the files."[3] Those files are at the National Archives.[4]
What the investigation concluded. At a Pentagon press conference on 29 July 1952, Major General John Samford said the visual sightings could be explained as misidentified stars or meteors, and the radar targets by temperature inversion, and that the radar contacts were not caused by solid material objects; a Civil Aeronautics Administration analysis found that an inversion "had been indicated in almost every instance."[5] Ruppelt saw it differently in 1956: the press took the inversion answer as the Air Force's verdict, "even though today the twin sightings are still carried as unknowns."[3] Wikipedia reports that Blue Book eventually labelled the radar blips as inversion effects and the visual sightings as misidentified meteors, stars and city lights.[5]
4. Petit-Rechain, Belgium, 1990: the triangle
Who and when. During the Belgian wave of triangle sightings in 1989-1991, a photo taken at Petit-Rechain on 4 April showed a black triangle lit at its corners and its centre, and went around the world.[6]
Where it is held. No museum or archive holds it as an official record. The best public record is the press report of the confession: Le Figaro, 28 July 2011.[6]
What it turned out to be. A hoax, by the photographer's own account. Le Figaro reported that researchers from France's CNRS, NASA and Belgium's Royal Military Academy had all failed to crack it, and that in July 2011 the photographer, named only as Patrick, then 41, admitted on the Belgian channel RTL-TVI that it was a piece of polystyrene fitted with lights, photographed with a friend as a joke on his workmates.[6] His words: "On ne pensait pas que ça sortirait de l'usine" (we never thought it would leave the factory).[6]
5-7. FLIR (2004), GIMBAL and GOFAST (2015): the Navy videos
Who and when. The three are infrared targeting-camera recordings from US Navy fighter jets. FLIR was recorded in November 2004 off southern California by Lt. Commander Chad Underwood of the USS Nimitz carrier group; GIMBAL and GOFAST were recorded by crews from the USS Theodore Roosevelt group off the US East Coast.[9] The New York Times published FLIR and GIMBAL on 16 December 2017, and the Washington Post published GOFAST.[9]
Where they are held. On 27 April 2020 the Department of Defense authorized the release of the three unclassified videos, "one taken in November 2004 and the other two in January 2015", which had circulated after unauthorized releases in 2007 and 2017. It said the Navy had already acknowledged them as Navy videos, and pointed to the NAVAIR FOIA Reading Room.[7] The reading room lists the GIMBAL and GOFAST video files for download: NAVAIR FOIA Reading Room.[8]
What the investigation concluded. Officially, nothing beyond "unidentified". The Pentagon said it released them "to clear up any misconceptions by the public on whether or not the footage that has been circulating was real", and that "The aerial phenomena observed in the videos remain characterized as 'unidentified.'"[7] Proposed explanations in public debate range from drones and instrument artifacts to parallax and human interpretive error.[9]
The claims
Everything in this section is a claim, attributed to the person who made it. None of it is established fact.
McMinnville. The ufologist Bruce Maccabee concluded from the negatives that the photos were not hoaxed and showed a "real, physical" object.[2] The skeptics Philip J. Klass and Robert Sheaffer concluded the opposite: that shadows showed morning light rather than evening, that the object was a small model hung from the power lines, possibly a vehicle's side mirror, and that the event was a hoax.[2] The Trents insisted until their deaths, in 1997 and 1998, that the sighting and the photos were genuine.[2]
Lubbock. The professors were "firmly convinced" Hart's photos were of "home manufacture", according to Ruppelt.[3] Ruppelt himself first suspected birds reflecting the light of mercury-vapor street lights, then wrote that an unnamed scientist had identified the professors' lights as "a very commonplace and easily explainable natural phenomenon", without saying what it was.[3]
Washington. Harry Barnes came away convinced "the UFOs were monitoring radio traffic and behaving accordingly", because on 20 July the targets vanished from the radar just before the jets arrived and came back once they had left.[5] A Navy radar specialist at the airport on the second weekend, Lt. John Holcomb, felt the inversion that night was not "nearly strong enough to explain the 'good and solid' returns."[5]
The Navy videos. Commander David Fravor, who flew in the 2004 Nimitz encounter, told a House Oversight hearing in 2023 that "the technology that we faced was far superior than anything that we had."[9] The science writer and skeptic Mick West takes the other side: he has said the recorded objects might well be commercial airplanes or balloons distorted by infrared glare, and that "A lack of data does not mean aliens are the likely answer".[9]
What the seven have in common
Line them up and a pattern shows. The famous image is rarely the strongest evidence: Washington's real record is radar logs, and Lubbock's best witnesses said the photos were wrong.[3][5] The one that defeated the laboratories, Petit-Rechain, was a polystyrene model.[6] The ones with the cleanest provenance, the Navy videos, come with an official label that says only what the word UFO always said: unidentified.[7]
FAQ
Are the Navy UFO videos real?
Yes, they are genuine Navy videos. The Department of Defense authorized their release on 27 April 2020, said the Navy had acknowledged them, and said the phenomena in them remain characterized as "unidentified."[7]
Where can I watch the official Navy UFO videos?
In the NAVAIR FOIA Reading Room, which the Department of Defense named as their official home.[7][8]
Was the famous Belgian triangle UFO photo a hoax?
Yes, by the photographer's own account on RTL-TVI in July 2011: polystyrene and lights, made as a joke on his workmates.[6]
Were the 1950 McMinnville UFO photos faked?
It has never been settled. The Condon Report's investigator said the evidence did not positively rule out a fabrication; Klass and Sheaffer later argued it was a hoax.[1][2]
Related: the UFO115 Evidence Timeline, with the sourced case files the Nimitz "Tic Tac" (2004), the 2023 UAP congressional hearing, the Belgian UFO wave (1989) and the Phoenix Lights (1997), the journal piece UAP vs UFO, and the Sky Watcher collection.
Sources
Every source below was opened and read on 2026-11-14. Dates are each source's own publication or update date.
- Scientific Study of Unidentified Flying Objects (Condon Report), Case 46: McMinnville, Oregon, 11 May 1950 (investigator William K. Hartmann), NCAS transcription. University of Colorado, for the US Air Force (transcribed by the National Capital Area Skeptics), 1968.
- McMinnville UFO photographs. Wikipedia, 2026-11-14.
- The Report on Unidentified Flying Objects (Edward J. Ruppelt), Project Gutenberg eBook #17346. Project Gutenberg (original edition 1956), 1956.
- Project BLUE BOOK - Unidentified Flying Objects. US National Archives and Records Administration, 2024-06-25.
- 1952 Washington, D.C., UFO incident. Wikipedia, 2026-11-14.
- La photo d'un ovni belge célèbre était un trucage (Tristan Vey). Le Figaro, 2011-07-28.
- Statement by the Department of Defense on the Release of Historical Navy Videos. US Department of Defense, 2020-04-27.
- NAVAIR FOIA Reading Room: Documents (Internet Archive copy of 19 October 2026). Naval Air Systems Command, US Navy, 2026-10-19.
- Pentagon UFO videos. Wikipedia, 2026-11-14.