On the evening of 4 August 1990, two men walking on the moors above the Perthshire hamlet of Calvine reportedly photographed a diamond-shaped object hovering near a jet that the Ministry of Defence took to be a Harrier [1][2][3]. The pictures went to the Daily Record, which never ran them, and the original prints and negatives later disappeared after reaching the Ministry [1][2]. One print, kept for decades by RAF press officer Craig Lindsay, was published in August 2022, and a photographic analyst found no sign of manipulation in the film or printing [1][3]. The photographers have never been publicly identified, and explanations range from a hoax to an experimental aircraft [2][3].
WHAT KIND OF CLAIM IS THIS?
- 2 DOCUMENTEDEstablished by records or contemporary reporting.
- 1 OFFICIALWhat an official body stated or concluded.
- 1 WITNESSWhat a witness reported. Not independently established.
- 2 DISPUTEDContested between sources.
- 2 ALLEGEDA claim made later, unsupported by the record.
- 1 DRAMATIZEDUFO115 reconstruction, not evidence.
- WITNESS Two men reported photographing a diamond-shaped object above Calvine, Perthshire, on the evening of 4 August 1990, and the pictures were passed to the Ministry of Defence. [1][3]
- OFFICIAL A Ministry of Defence note said no definite conclusions had been reached about the diamond-shaped object, that the jet was confidently a Harrier, and that it had no record of Harriers operating there at that date and time. [2]
- DOCUMENTED Ministry documents on the Calvine case, including a September 1990 briefing and a handwritten summary, were released through the National Archives. [1]
- DOCUMENTED Andrew Robinson's analysis found the image to be a genuine photograph of a scene before the camera and found no evidence of staging in front of it, though he did not rule staging out. [1][3]
- DISPUTED The original negatives and prints disappeared after reaching the Ministry; the Ministry says it returned the negatives to the Daily Record, while the paper says it never received them. [1][3]
- ALLEGED A former Defence Intelligence officer told David Clarke that Ministry staff knew the object was an experimental craft belonging to the US. [1][2]
- ALLEGED Richard Grieve said two men in dark suits spoke to the hikers at their hotel and that the pair vanished without trace four weeks later. [2]
- DISPUTED Sean Kirkpatrick says the image is a reflection in a lake and has been doctored, although the Guardian notes there is no body of water on the hillside. [1][2]
- DRAMATIZED A 2015 Channel 5 reconstruction of the photograph was republished by some outlets and mistaken by some for the genuine image. [1]
WHAT HAPPENED
According to the account first given to the Daily Record, two men were walking on the moors above Calvine in Perthshire on the evening of 4 August 1990 [1][3]. They said they saw a diamond-shaped craft, took shelter under nearby trees and photographed it while it hovered silently, before it rose vertically and vanished [1]. Reports say it hovered for about ten minutes [4]. Nick Pope's 1996 description adds that a jet made several low passes as if the pilot had seen the object too, and that six photographs were taken [1]. The Guardian describes the same jet as a Harrier circling the diamond [2].
What is documented is narrower than the story. The pictures reached the Daily Record, which did not publish them, and the paper's picture editor sent the best print to RAF press officer Craig Lindsay [1][2]. Lindsay forwarded it to the Ministry of Defence, which asked for the other photographs and the negatives [2]. Those items went to London and have not been seen since [2][3]. One print stayed with Lindsay and was published in August 2022 [1][2].
Ministry documents on the Calvine case, including a September 1990 briefing and a handwritten summary, were released through the National Archives.
BACKGROUND
The existence of the photographs first reached the public in 1996, in Nick Pope's book Open Skies, Closed Minds [1][2]. Pope worked on the Ministry of Defence UFO desk from 1991 to 1994, arriving a year after the sighting [1][2]. He called Calvine one of the most intriguing cases in the Ministry's files and wrote that its analysis found the photos were "not fakes" and recorded the case as "object unexplained, case closed, no further action" [1][2]. He also said a poster-sized print hung on his office wall until his Head of Division had it removed [1].
The case drew little attention until the National Archives began releasing Ministry UFO files, with David Clarke invited to supervise the release [1]. The papers included a handwritten summary and a briefing, both dated September 1990, plus poor-quality photocopies of transparencies made from cropped versions of the photographs [1]. A note intended for defence ministers said no definite conclusions had been reached about the diamond-shaped object, that the jet was confidently a Harrier, and that the Ministry had no record of Harriers operating there at the stated date and time [2]. In 2015 a Channel 5 series reconstructed the scene on the moors above Calvine [1].
CHRONOLOGY
Two men reportedly photograph a diamond-shaped object and a jet on the moors above Calvine. [1][3]
The Daily Record sends the best print to RAF press officer Craig Lindsay, who forwards it to the Ministry of Defence and later phones one of the hikers. [2]
A Ministry briefing and a handwritten summary of the sighting are dated this month. [1]
Nick Pope describes the Calvine photographs in his book Open Skies, Closed Minds. [1][2]
Ministry of Defence documents released by the National Archives include partial documentation of the Calvine sighting. [1][2]
Channel 5's Conspiracy series features the case, with a reconstructed image of the photograph. [1]
David Clarke renews his investigation after a former Defence Intelligence officer's name is left unredacted. [1][2]
Lindsay agrees to donate the print and other items to Sheffield Hallam University's Special Collection. [1]
The photograph is published in the Daily Mail, with an online release the night before. [1]
WITNESS ACCOUNTS
The two photographers have never spoken publicly about the pictures [2]. What is known of their account comes second-hand. Lindsay phoned one of them, who turned out to be working in a hotel in Pitlochry, and was given the whole story: the diamond, the jet, and an object that hovered with no sound and accelerated with no obvious propellant [1][2]. The Guardian says the pair were chefs at Fisher's Hotel in Pitlochry [2]. Clarke's retelling of what the hikers said is that they ran into woodland to keep their heads down, heard a jet come down the valley, and took the photographs when it came back two minutes later and circled the object [3].
Lindsay also described seeing a poster-size print on a wall at the Ministry in London in autumn 1990 [2]. Staff showed him the other frames, in which the Harrier moved from the right of the picture to the left while the diamond did not move [2]. Specialists told him there was no evidence of a hoax but that they did not know what the object was [2]. A separate account comes from Richard Grieve, who told the documentary The Program that he worked with the hikers in the hotel kitchen and described two men in dark suits arriving by car and speaking to them [2]. Grieve said the pair came back looking shaken, were not the same afterwards and vanished without trace four weeks later [2].

#NOMORESECRETS
WEAR THE STORY.
Government Denial Is Futile Tee
Government Denial Is Futile Poster
Area 51 Black Triangle Tee
Sky Watcher Ring of Fire Tee
WHAT THE INVESTIGATIONS FOUND
Clarke says the Ministry analysed the images in 1990 and 1992, and he has called for those conclusions to be released [2]. The released files show the images were investigated by DI55, a branch of the Directorate of Scientific and Technical Intelligence, and by an RAF photo analyst agency [1]. In 2018 Clarke found that the Ministry had failed to redact the name of a former Defence Intelligence official, who told him that people at the Ministry knew the object was an experimental craft belonging to the US [1][2]. That trail led to Lindsay, who in June 2022 agreed to donate the original print to Sheffield Hallam University's Special Collection and handed it to Clarke [1].
Andrew Robinson, a senior lecturer in photography at Sheffield Hallam, analysed it [1][2]. His report concludes that the image is a genuine photograph of a scene before the camera [1]. It adds that the picture shows either a genuine unidentified flying object or something constructed in front of the camera, not in the film or printing [3]. He found no evidence of staging, though he did not rule it out [1]. The back of the print carries a red credit reading "Copyright Kevin Russell c/o Daily Record GLASGOW" [2]. The Daily Record said no one of that name had worked there, and a search of Kevin Russells found nobody who admitted involvement [1][2]. The Ministry has said it no longer comments on UFOs [2], and the photographers' identities are not expected to be released before 2072 [3].
EXPLANATIONS
Several explanations have been put forward, and none is established. Clarke does not think the object came from another galaxy; he believes it was man-made and has suggested the rumoured Aurora aircraft, while noting there is no substantial evidence that Aurora was ever built [3]. The Defence Intelligence source he spoke to said Ministry staff knew it was an experimental US craft [2]. The same source suggested it had been flown from RAF Machrihanish, escorted by UK and US aircraft [1]. Some ufologists instead argue that because it looks like no known aircraft it must be an alien spaceship, or a craft recreated from a crashed alien vessel [2].
Sceptics offer simpler readings. Sean Kirkpatrick, former director of the Pentagon's All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office, says it is a reflection in a lake and that the image was doctored [1][2]. The Guardian notes there is no body of water on that hillside [2]. Others suggest a cardboard bauble hung from a string on a tree branch [1][2]. The Ministry pointed the Guardian to a Daily Express idea that the diamond is a fog-covered mountain peak, which Clarke says his photography expert has debunked [2]. Clarke also allows that the whole thing could be a prank that got out of hand [3].
WHAT REMAINS DISPUTED
The largest gap is the identity of the photographers. Clarke says they have never come forward despite the publicity [3]. Pope declined to comment on names, suggested that "a fairly robust conversation" was held at the outset, and called claims that the witnesses were assassinated "nonsense" [1][2]. The negatives are also unresolved: the Ministry says it returned them to the Daily Record, while the paper says it never received them [3].
Why the story went unpublished is disputed too. Pope has said the Ministry prevented release of the photographs and that publication would have undermined its standard line [2]. The Guardian notes that the Record's 1990 editor sat on the Ministry's D notice committee, but says this could be coincidence and that it is not known whether the paper received a notice [2]. Clarke at one point thought the paper may have judged the pictures a hoax [2]. The sources document a lost chain of custody, and none establishes what the object was [2][3].
QUESTIONS PEOPLE ASK
What is the Calvine UFO photograph?
It is a photograph said to have been taken on the evening of 4 August 1990 by one of two men walking near Calvine in Perthshire, showing a diamond-shaped object and a jet [1][3]. It was published in the Daily Mail on 13 August 2022 [1].
Is the Calvine photograph genuine?
Andrew Robinson of Sheffield Hallam University concluded that the image is a genuine photograph of a scene before the camera and found no evidence of staging, though he did not rule it out [1]. Sean Kirkpatrick says it is a reflection in a lake and that the photo has been doctored, although there is no body of water on that hillside [2].
What was the jet in the picture?
A Ministry of Defence note said it was confidently a Harrier, though the Ministry had no record of Harriers operating there at that date and time [2].
Who took the Calvine photographs?
Nobody has confirmed this. The photographers were reported to be two men working in a Pitlochry hotel, but their identities remain unknown despite searches led by David Clarke [1][2]. The name Kevin Russell is written on the back of the print, but the one Kevin Russell traced to a kitchen job in the area denied any knowledge of the UFO [1][2].
THE RECONSTRUCTION

A moorland hillside at dusk with a dark diamond-shaped object hanging still above the ridge and a small jet far to one side. It shows what the hikers reported, not what was there.
AI-generated artistic reconstruction. UFO115 dramatization, not evidence and not a photograph of the event. Hero image source: UFO115 reconstruction (local AI model, 2026).
SOURCES
- Calvine UFO photograph. Wikipedia, read 2026-11-15. Read 2026-11-15. Link checked 2026-11-15 (HTTP 200).
- What really happened in Calvine? The mystery behind the best UFO picture ever seen. The Guardian, 2025-02-11. Read 2026-11-15. Link checked 2026-11-15 (HTTP 200).
- 'Best' UFO Picture Ever, the Calvine Photo, Found After 30 Years Missing. Newsweek, 2022-08-15. Read 2026-11-15. Link checked 2026-11-15 (HTTP 200).
- 'World's clearest UFO photo' taken in UK was hidden from public for years. LADbible, 2024-04-04. Read 2026-11-15. Link checked 2026-11-15 (HTTP 200).
CITE THIS RECORD
UFO115. "The Calvine UFO Photograph — 1990." UFO115 Evidence Timeline, record UFO115-INC-1990-001, version 1. Last reviewed 2026-11-15. https://ufo115.com/evidence-timeline/incidents/calvine-photograph-1990
APA: UFO115. (2026). The Calvine UFO Photograph — 1990 (Record UFO115-INC-1990-001, v1). UFO115 Evidence Timeline. https://ufo115.com/evidence-timeline/incidents/calvine-photograph-1990
MLA: "The Calvine UFO Photograph — 1990." UFO115 Evidence Timeline, UFO115, 2026-11-15, https://ufo115.com/evidence-timeline/incidents/calvine-photograph-1990.
Last reviewed by The UFO115 desk. Record UFO115-INC-1990-001, version 1. Machine-readable record.
“NO MORE SECRETS” is UFO115's editorial framing, not a claim that events happened as dramatized.