On the evening of 12 September 1952, a group of local boys, Kathleen May and National Guardsman Eugene Lemon reported a bright light crossing the sky and then a tall figure with a spade-shaped head on a hillside farm in Flatwoods, West Virginia [1][3]. According to a former news editor, the story was carried in newspapers throughout the country and on large radio networks [1]. Some of the group later reported nausea and swollen throats, and the search by local authorities that night found nothing [1][3]. In 2000 Joe Nickell of the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry proposed a meteor, an aircraft beacon and a barn owl, while Gray Barker and Ivan T. Sanderson concluded that the group had met an extraterrestrial craft and its occupant [1][4].
WHAT KIND OF CLAIM IS THIS?
- 2 DOCUMENTEDEstablished by records or contemporary reporting.
- 1 OFFICIALWhat an official body stated or concluded.
- 2 WITNESSWhat a witness reported. Not independently established.
- 2 DISPUTEDContested between sources.
- 1 ALLEGEDA claim made later, unsupported by the record.
- 1 DRAMATIZEDUFO115 reconstruction, not evidence.
- WITNESS On 12 September 1952, Edward and Fred May and Tommy Hyer reported a bright object crossing the sky and landing on G. Bailey Fisher's farm. [1]
- WITNESS Eugene Lemon said he briefly saw a tall figure with a round, red face inside a pointed, hood-like shape when he aimed his flashlight toward the light. [1]
- DOCUMENTED According to former news editor Holt Byrne, the story was carried in newspapers throughout the country and on large radio networks. [1]
- DOCUMENTED The sheriff and a deputy searched the site where the figure was said to have been and saw, heard and smelled nothing. [1][3]
- OFFICIAL Nickell concluded that the light was most likely a meteor, the red light likely an aircraft beacon and aspects of the figure resembled an owl, and Wikipedia says Air Force investigators share his conclusions. [1]
- ALLEGED A. Lee Stewart Jr. of the Braxton Democrat was said to have found skid marks and a gummy deposit the next day, later cited as evidence of a saucer landing. [1]
- DISPUTED Barker and Sanderson concluded that the group met an extraterrestrial craft and its occupant, a view Haupt does not accept. [4]
- DISPUTED Skeptoid's Ryan Haupt attributes the illness to hysteria and over-exertion, while the tourism article notes the symptoms are also signs of mustard gas exposure. [3][4]
- DRAMATIZED The legend is the basis of an episode of the television series Project Blue Book and is referenced in the video game Fallout 76. [1][5]
WHAT HAPPENED
At 7:15 p.m. on 12 September 1952, brothers Edward and Fred May and their friend Tommy Hyer reported seeing a bright object cross the sky and land on the property of farmer G. Bailey Fisher in Flatwoods, West Virginia [1]. A tourism article from Braxton County says it was almost fully dark and that the light seemed to crash into a hillside [3]. The boys told their mother, Kathleen May, and the group then went to the farm, joined by other local children and by her cousin, West Virginia National Guardsman Eugene Lemon [1].
At the top of a hill, the group reported a red, pulsating light [1][3]. Lemon said he aimed a flashlight that way and briefly saw a tall figure with a round, red face inside a pointed, hood-like shape [1]. According to the account, the figure hissed and glided toward the group, Lemon yelled and dropped his flashlight, and everyone ran [1]. The group also reported a pungent mist [1]. The local sheriff and a deputy, who had been looking into reports of a crashed aircraft, searched the spot where the figure was said to have stood and saw, heard and smelled nothing [1].
According to former news editor Holt Byrne, the story was carried in newspapers throughout the country and on large radio networks.
BACKGROUND
Flatwoods is a town in Braxton County, West Virginia. A museum dedicated to the story operates in Sutton, a few miles to the south [3]. Gray Barker, one of the writers who later investigated, grew up in Braxton County [4].
Skeptoid's account places the sighting between Kenneth Arnold's report of unidentified craft, which the media called flying saucers, and the start of the Space Race, and argues that people were looking at the sky expecting to see something [4]. The same source says a meteor was reported that night in at least three states: West Virginia, Pennsylvania and Maryland [4]. It also says Sheriff Robert Carr was away from his station because he had been called out to investigate a plane crash reported by Woodrow Eagle, who had seen a light in the sky disappear into the mountains [4].
The Visit Braxton article, written by an employee of the Flatwoods Monster Museum, adds two further reports. In one, Audra Harper said she saw a similar figure near Heaters not long before the Fisher farm sighting [3]. In the other, George and Edith Snitowsky reported a creature hovering in front of their car on a road the day after, and Snitowsky gave his account to Male Magazine in July 1955 [3]. Both rest on that single source.
CHRONOLOGY
Edward and Fred May and Tommy Hyer report a bright object crossing the sky and landing on G. Bailey Fisher's farm. [1]
Kathleen May, Eugene Lemon and several children go to the farm, report a red pulsating light, and Lemon's flashlight shows a tall figure. [1][3]
Local authorities, the sheriff and a deputy, search the site and find nothing. [1][3]
A. Lee Stewart Jr. of the Braxton Democrat is said to have found skid marks and a gummy deposit; a separate encounter is reported near Strange Creek. [1][3]
Ivan T. Sanderson arrives to investigate, and Gray Barker also visits. [4]
George Snitowsky gives his account of the Strange Creek encounter to Male Magazine. [3]
Joe Nickell proposes a meteor and a barn owl, along with an aircraft beacon. [1]
Project Blue Book airs an episode based on the incident, and Flatwoods begins hosting the Flatwoods Monster Convention. [1]
WITNESS ACCOUNTS
The accounts differ in detail. Skeptoid notes that even reports made within days vary, and that sources disagree on how many boys were present and who they were [4]. Wikipedia lists Edward and Fred May, Tommy Hyer, Neil Nunley, Ronnie Shaver, Kathleen May and Eugene Lemon [1]. Skeptoid describes a group of seven, lists Teddie Neal among them, names Tommy Hyer only as possibly present, and describes Lemon as a 17-year-old national guardsman [4]. A Braxton County tourism official said the group was made up of boys aged roughly 10 to 17 and two of the boys' mothers [2].
Nunley said they saw a red, pulsating light [1]. Lemon described a tall "man-like figure with a round, red face surrounded by a pointed, hood-like shape" [1]. Gray Barker, working from tape-recorded interviews, wrote that the figure stood about 10 feet (3 m) tall, with a blood-red face, eyelike features giving off a greenish-orange light, and small, claw-like hands [1]. The Visit Braxton article describes a head shaped like a spade and a dark, metal-looking dress, and says the figure seemed to levitate [3]. Skeptoid gives a height range of seven to 12 feet [4].
Afterwards some of the group reported nausea. Mrs May noticed an oily film on the boys' faces, their throats became swollen, and a doctor was called to examine them; no apparent cause was found [1].

#NOMORESECRETS
WEAR THE STORY.
Alien Races Lineup Poster
Field Guide to Alien Races Canvas
Alien Races Lineup Tee
Field Guide to Alien Races Tee
WHAT THE INVESTIGATIONS FOUND
The sheriff and a deputy searched the site and found nothing; the tourism article says the search took place that night [1][3]. Skeptoid gives a different picture of the return visit. It says Lemon led an armed party back, that the craft and creature were gone, and that they found a faint sulphur smell, track marks in the grass and some oily residue with bits of a black, rubber-like substance [4]. According to Barker's account, A. Lee Stewart Jr. of the Braxton Democrat said he found skid marks and an odd, gummy deposit the next day, and UFO enthusiast groups later cited these as evidence of a saucer landing [1].
Barker and the naturalist Ivan T. Sanderson both visited Flatwoods, with Sanderson arriving as early as 18 September [4]. They explored the site, interviewed witnesses and wrote reports that were later published, and both concluded that the group had met an extraterrestrial craft and its occupant [4]. Sanderson's 36-page report described at least five objects travelling in a straight line, with one landing outside Flatwoods [4].
The story drew heavy coverage. Former news editor Holt Byrne said it was carried in newspapers and on large radio networks, and that hundreds of calls came in [1]. Apart from Wikipedia's statement that Air Force investigators share Nickell's conclusions, these sources do not describe a government report on the case [1].
EXPLANATIONS
After investigating in 2000, Joe Nickell of the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry concluded that the bright light was most likely a meteor, that the pulsing red light was likely an aircraft beacon, and that features of the figure resembled an owl [1]. According to Nickell, three flashing red aircraft beacons were visible from the area [1]. He judged that the shape, movement and sounds were consistent with a startled barn owl perched on a tree limb, and researchers concluded that foliage beneath it may have created the illusion of a pleated green skirt [1]. He also suggested that the witnesses' perceptions were distorted by anxiety [1]. Wikipedia says other investigators, including those of the Air Force, share these conclusions [1].
Ryan Haupt of Skeptoid supports this reading. He adds that fog is common in the Appalachians, that West Virginia's natural sulphur springs make it reasonable that a nearby spring or cave produced the smell, and that the illness fits hysteria and over-exertion [4]. He notes that a local boy, Max Lockard, said he had driven his Chevy truck around the site hoping to see something [1][4]. Haupt does not doubt the witnesses' honesty [4].
Skeptoid also lists explanations offered at the time: a school teacher's suggestion of a plane beacon and a meteor trail, an idea supposedly from a noted scientist that a meteor fragment disintegrated into vapour, a religious sign, and a Wisconsin cheese company's suggestion of an inflated rubber cow launched as a publicity stunt [4]. Sanderson rejected all of them [4].
WHAT REMAINS DISPUTED
The main disagreement is over what the group saw. Barker and Sanderson concluded it was an extraterrestrial craft and its occupant, while Nickell and Haupt favour a meteor, beacon and owl [1][4]. Haupt accepts that something was in the sky and that the group had a real fright, and he does not see signs of a hoax in how the group formed [4].
The illness is also contested. The Visit Braxton article says the symptoms were put down to hysteria but notes that they are also signs of mustard gas exposure [3]. Skeptoid reports the same mustard gas comparison but favours hysteria and over-exertion [4]. Wikipedia says a doctor was called to examine the boys and no apparent cause was found [1].
The physical traces are described inconsistently. The sheriff's party found nothing, while later accounts mention tracks, residue and rubbery material that could have come from a truck [1][4]. The Visit Braxton article says the monster has not been seen since the original incidents in 1952 [3].
The story has since become part of local culture. Flatwoods has a welcome sign calling it the "Home of the Green Monster" and has hosted the Flatwoods Monster Convention since 2019, while Braxton County has five monster-shaped chairs and a museum in Sutton [1][3]. It has also appeared in an episode of Project Blue Book and in the game Fallout 76 [1][5].
QUESTIONS PEOPLE ASK
What was the Flatwoods Monster?
It is an alleged humanoid reportedly sighted in Flatwoods, West Virginia, on 12 September 1952, after a bright light moved across the night sky [1]. Witnesses described a tall figure with a head like the ace of spades and a red face [1].
Who saw the Flatwoods Monster?
The group included Kathleen May, Eugene Lemon and several boys, among them Edward and Fred May, Neil Nunley and Ronnie Shaver [1]. Sources differ on exactly who was present [4].
How tall was the Flatwoods Monster said to be?
Barker's account, based on witness interviews, gives about 10 feet (3 m) [1]. Skeptoid says reports range from seven to 12 feet [4].
THE RECONSTRUCTION

A hillside farm at dusk with an oak tree on the ridge, mist in the hollow and a red glow low above the ground. It shows what the group reported seeing, not what was there. Small figures walk up the slope, seen from behind.
AI-generated artistic reconstruction. UFO115 dramatization, not evidence and not a photograph of the event. Hero image source: UFO115 reconstruction (local AI model, 2026).
SOURCES
- Flatwoods monster. Wikipedia, read 2026-11-14. Read 2026-11-14. Link checked 2026-11-14 (HTTP 200).
- Braxie helps to promote 'monstrous' tourism in Flatwoods area. WV MetroNews, 2017-07-16. Read 2026-11-14. Link checked 2026-11-14 (HTTP 200).
- The Flatwoods Monster. Visit Braxton, WV (braxtonwv.org), read 2026-11-14. Read 2026-11-14. Link checked 2026-11-14 (HTTP 200).
- The Braxton County Monster. Skeptoid (Ryan Haupt), 2014-09-30. Read 2026-11-14. Link checked 2026-11-14 (HTTP 200).
- Video game to be based in a post-apocalyptic Mountain State. Herald-Dispatch, read 2026-11-14. Read 2026-11-14. Link checked 2026-11-14 (HTTP 200).
CITE THIS RECORD
UFO115. "The Flatwoods Monster — 1952." UFO115 Evidence Timeline, record UFO115-INC-1952-002, version 1. Last reviewed 2026-11-14. https://ufo115.com/evidence-timeline/incidents/flatwoods-monster-1952
APA: UFO115. (2026). The Flatwoods Monster — 1952 (Record UFO115-INC-1952-002, v1). UFO115 Evidence Timeline. https://ufo115.com/evidence-timeline/incidents/flatwoods-monster-1952
MLA: "The Flatwoods Monster — 1952." UFO115 Evidence Timeline, UFO115, 2026-11-14, https://ufo115.com/evidence-timeline/incidents/flatwoods-monster-1952.
Last reviewed by The UFO115 desk. Record UFO115-INC-1952-002, version 1. Machine-readable record.
“NOT OF THIS EARTH” is UFO115's editorial framing, not a claim that events happened as dramatized.