Black Friday: S4 Declassification opens Nov 27, 2:14 AM ET

UFO115
Sign in Cartitems: 0
Artistic reconstruction: an open manila folder of typed pages with black redaction bars on a wooden desk under a brass lamp at night, a 35 mm film canister and its lid beside it. AI-generated.

THE FILE THEY CLOSED

Majestic 12 (MJ-12) Documents — 1984

One roll of film. Twelve names. A file the FBI called completely bogus.

UFO115-INC-1984-00111 December 1984Los Angeles area, California (film received by Jaime Shandera); later the National Archives, Washington, D.C., United StatesDisputed

AI-generated artistic reconstruction. UFO115 dramatization, not evidence and not an image of the MJ-12 documents.

In December 1984 an unmarked package containing an undeveloped roll of 35 mm film reached Jaime Shandera, a television producer and friend of Roswell author William Moore [4][5]. The film showed pages said to be a 1952 briefing for President-elect Eisenhower about "Majestic-12", a secret panel Truman supposedly formed in 1947 to study a crashed saucer [4][6]. The National Archives found serious problems with a related memo, and in December 1988 the FBI told its Dallas office the document was "completely bogus" [1][2].

WHAT KIND OF CLAIM IS THIS?

  • 2 DOCUMENTEDEstablished by records or contemporary reporting.
  • 3 OFFICIALWhat an official body stated or concluded.
  • 1 WITNESSWhat a witness reported. Not independently established.
  • 1 DISPUTEDContested between sources.
  • 2 ALLEGEDA claim made later, unsupported by the record.
  1. DOCUMENTED An undeveloped roll of 35 mm film carrying images of papers about "Majestic-12" reached Jaime Shandera in December 1984 from an unknown sender. [4][5][6]
  2. ALLEGED The papers describe a secret panel of twelve, authorised by President Truman in September 1947, that studied a crashed disc and bodies recovered in New Mexico. [4][8]
  3. OFFICIAL The National Archives found that the Cutler-Twining memo lacked a register number and watermark, bore a marking not used until the Nixon administration, and was dated a day Cutler was abroad. [2]
  4. OFFICIAL In December 1988 FBI headquarters told its Dallas office that, according to the Air Force, the MJ-12 document was fabricated and completely bogus, and closed the case. [1][6]
  5. OFFICIAL A 1997 CIA history states that most if not all of the MJ-12 documents have proved to be fabrications. [3][8]
  6. DOCUMENTED Philip Klass reported that the Truman signature was a photocopy of one on a genuine 1 October 1947 letter, and that the briefing paper's date style matched Moore's letters. [4][5]
  7. WITNESS Moore said at a 1989 MUFON conference that he had passed information on other researchers to Air Force agents. [6][8]
  8. DISPUTED Who created the documents, and whether they were a private hoax or official disinformation, is contested. [4][6][8]
  9. ALLEGED Proponents maintain that credible documents show Majestic 12 operating under Truman and Eisenhower. [7]

WHAT HAPPENED

Skeptic Philip Klass gives the date of delivery as 11 December 1984 [5]. Moore described the package as plain brown paper sealed with tape, holding a second wrapper, then an envelope, then a film can [4]. There was no return address. Shandera phoned Moore before the roll was processed, and Moore was there when it was developed [4].

The frames showed two papers marked Top Secret. One looked like a memo from President Truman to Defense Secretary James Forrestal, dated 24 September 1947, telling him and Vannevar Bush to go ahead with "Operation Majestic-12" [4]. The other ran to seven pages and looked like a briefing prepared for President-elect Eisenhower on 18 November 1952 [4]. It named twelve members, with Admiral Roscoe Hillenkoetter, who had headed the CIA in 1947, listed as MJ-1 [4][8]. It described the recovery of a crashed disc and four bodies in New Mexico in mid-1947, and a second wreck near the Texas-Mexico border in December 1950 [4][5].

An undeveloped roll of 35 mm film carrying images of papers about "Majestic-12" reached Jaime Shandera in December 1984 from an unknown sender.

BACKGROUND

The film did not arrive in a vacuum. In 1980 Moore and Charles Berlitz had published The Roswell Incident, which argued that the military recovered a crashed saucer in New Mexico in 1947 [4][5]. Moore and Stanton Friedman, a nuclear physicist turned UFO lecturer, had searched archives in Washington for proof in 1981 and 1982 [4][5]. Klass noted that in 1982, two years before the film appeared, Moore told a conference that Vannevar Bush would have been the logical man to run a secret crash project [4].

The wider setting matters too. Wikipedia's summary of the later record says that after his book came out, Moore was approached by men presenting themselves as Air Force intelligence officers, including Richard Doty, who dangled the promise of crash evidence while Moore kept notes on other researchers [8]. The phrase "MJ Twelve" had already appeared in a 1981 paper used to mislead the Albuquerque researcher Paul Bennewitz [8]. Moore himself later spoke about that relationship in public [6].

CHRONOLOGY

  1. Moore and Charles Berlitz publish The Roswell Incident. [4][5]

  2. Shandera receives an unmarked package holding an undeveloped roll of 35 mm film; developed, it shows the Truman memo and the Eisenhower briefing paper. [4][5][8]

  3. Moore and Shandera find the Cutler-Twining memo among newly opened Air Force files at the National Archives. [2][4]

  4. Timothy Good tells the British press about the papers; on 29 May Moore, Shandera and Friedman release them. [4][6]

  5. A National Archives memo questions the Cutler-Twining memo; CSICOP calls the papers clumsy counterfeits. [2][4]

  6. Air Force OSI brings the document to the FBI in Dallas; FBI headquarters calls it completely bogus and closes the case. [1]

  7. Moore tells a MUFON conference he informed on fellow researchers for Air Force agents. [6]

  8. Klass reports that the Truman signature is a photocopied transplant. [5]

  9. A CIA history states that most if not all MJ-12 documents have proved to be fabrications. [3]

WHO MADE THE CLAIMS

There are no eyewitnesses to a saucer in this file, only the people who received and promoted paper. Shandera received the film. Moore told the story of its arrival and controlled the documents for more than two years [4]. In July 1985, after Friedman told him that boxes of old Air Force intelligence files were being opened at the National Archives, Moore and Shandera went to Washington and found a carbon memo from Eisenhower aide Robert Cutler to General Nathan Twining, dated 14 July 1954, that mentioned an "NSC/MJ-12 Special Studies Project" [4][2].

In mid-May 1987 the British author Timothy Good told the press he had the documents from an American source [4]. Moore, Shandera and Friedman released their set on 29 May 1987, saying the papers appeared to be genuine while stopping short of endorsing them [4][5]. Friedman became their best-known defender [5]. Some later proponents still argue for them: the Majestic Documents site run by Robert and Ryan Wood says credible papers show Majestic 12 activity under Eisenhower and gives each document a weighted authenticity rating [7].

#NOMORESECRETS

WEAR THE STORY.

The full collection

WHAT THE INVESTIGATIONS FOUND

The National Archives examined the one item found in its own stacks, the Cutler-Twining memo. Its reference report says the memo had none of the Top Secret register numbers carried by other papers in the series, and that no other paper in the folder mentioned the project [2]. The National Security Council told the Archives that the marking "Top Secret Restricted Information" was not used until the Nixon administration [2]. Cutler's genuine papers carry an eagle watermark; this one did not. Minutes show no NSC meeting on 16 July 1954, and Eisenhower's appointment books show no such briefing [2]. Cutler was touring military bases in Europe and North Africa on the day the memo is dated [2].

The FBI file tells a shorter story. On 15 September 1988 an agent of the Air Force Office of Special Investigations contacted the Dallas office about a copy of the briefing paper that had arrived in the mail [1][8]. A teletype from FBI headquarters dated 2 December 1988 says the Air Force advised on 30 November that the document was fabricated, that copies had spread across the country, and that it was completely bogus. Dallas was told to close the case [1]. A CIA history by Gerald Haines, published in 1997, says most if not all of the MJ-12 papers have proved to be fabrications [3][8].

EXPLANATIONS

Klass made the case for forgery in detail. In his first report he showed that every date in the briefing paper used a mixed style, such as "18 November, 1952", with a needless comma and leading zeros on single-digit days [4]. He said Moore's own letters to him used the same style, and that Moore switched to the leading zero in the autumn of 1983 [4]. In 1990 Klass reported that the Truman signature on the 1947 memo matched one on a real letter Truman sent Bush on 1 October 1947, including a small slip of the pen. A document examiner told him it was a photocopied transplant, typed on a Smith-Corona machine that first appeared in 1963 [5].

Others point to deliberate disinformation rather than a lone forger. Brian Dunning of Skeptoid links the film to Air Force efforts in the 1980s to feed false alien stories to UFO researchers watching sensitive bases [6]. At a MUFON conference in 1989 Moore admitted passing information on fellow researchers to Air Force agents, and he said he believed the film was a reward [6]. None of the sources reviewed here names the person who typed the papers.

WHAT REMAINS DISPUTED

The question of authorship is open. Klass suspected Moore and noted that Moore never answered whether he was Good's source [4]. Dunning notes that the Air Force statement that the paper was fabricated is generally taken to mean the Air Force made it, though the wording does not say so [6]. Even the package is unclear: Dunning reports an Albuquerque postmark, while Klass wrote that Moore never sent him a copy of it [6][4].

The defenders did not all hold their ground. Wikipedia's summary says Friedman kept defending the 1984 papers but in 2009 called a later batch, passed to researcher Timothy Cooper, fiction [8]. The official record is consistent on the core point. The Archives found nothing in the files of the Air Force, the Joint Chiefs, the NSC or the Truman and Eisenhower libraries to support the project [2], the FBI closed its case [1], and the CIA history calls the papers fabrications [3]. Interest in Majestic 12 continues, but the documents that started it have not survived examination.

THE RECONSTRUCTION

Artistic reconstruction: an open manila folder of typed pages with black redaction bars on a wooden desk under a brass lamp at night, a 35 mm film canister and its lid beside it. AI-generated.
AI RECONSTRUCTIONAI-generated artistic reconstruction. UFO115 dramatization, not evidence and not an image of the MJ-12 documents.

An AI-generated still life, not a photograph of any real evidence: at night a worn manila folder lies open on an old wooden desk under a brass lamp, its yellowed typed pages blurred and illegible with black bars across some lines, while a small 35 mm film canister and its lid sit beside it and cold blue light falls through window blinds. It suggests the kind of package described in 1984 and shows no real document, seal or person.

AI-generated artistic reconstruction. UFO115 dramatization, not evidence and not an image of the MJ-12 documents. Hero image source: UFO115 reconstruction (local AI model, 2026).

SOURCES

  1. Majestic 12, Part 1 of 1 (FBI file 65-81170). Federal Bureau of Investigation, FBI Records: The Vault (archived copy), 1988; declassified 28 August 1991. Read 2026-11-13. Link checked 2026-11-14 (HTTP 403); archived copy HTTP 200. Archived copy.
  2. Records Relating to Unidentified Flying Objects (UFOs): Majestic 12 or "MJ-12" Reference Report. U.S. National Archives and Records Administration, page last reviewed 25 June 2024. Read 2026-11-13. Link checked 2026-11-14 (HTTP 200).
  3. CIA's Role in the Study of UFOs, 1947-90 (Gerald K. Haines). Central Intelligence Agency, Center for the Study of Intelligence (Studies in Intelligence), 1997 (Studies in Intelligence; year from the Wikipedia citation, the PDF itself is undated). Read 2026-11-13. Link checked 2026-11-14 (HTTP 200).
  4. The MJ-12 Crashed-Saucer Documents (Philip J. Klass). Skeptical Inquirer, vol. 12, no. 2 (Center for Inquiry PDF), Winter 1987-88. Read 2026-11-13. Link checked 2026-11-14 (HTTP 200).
  5. New Evidence of MJ-12 Hoax (Philip J. Klass). Skeptical Inquirer, vol. 14, no. 2 (Center for Inquiry PDF), Winter 1990. Read 2026-11-13. Link checked 2026-11-14 (HTTP 200).
  6. Skeptoid #528: The Secret History of Majestic 12 (Brian Dunning). Skeptoid, 19 July 2016. Read 2026-11-13. Link checked 2026-11-14 (HTTP 200).
  7. Majestic Documents (home page and Authenticity Ratings). majesticdocuments.com (Robert M. Wood and Ryan S. Wood), read 2026-11-13. Read 2026-11-13. Link checked 2026-11-14 (HTTP 200).
  8. Majestic 12. Wikipedia, read 2026-11-13. Read 2026-11-13. Link checked 2026-11-14 (HTTP 200).

CITE THIS RECORD

UFO115. "Majestic 12 (MJ-12) Documents — 1984." UFO115 Evidence Timeline, record UFO115-INC-1984-001, version 1. Last reviewed 2026-11-14. https://ufo115.com/evidence-timeline/incidents/majestic-12-1984

APA: UFO115. (2026). Majestic 12 (MJ-12) Documents — 1984 (Record UFO115-INC-1984-001, v1). UFO115 Evidence Timeline. https://ufo115.com/evidence-timeline/incidents/majestic-12-1984

MLA: "Majestic 12 (MJ-12) Documents — 1984." UFO115 Evidence Timeline, UFO115, 2026-11-14, https://ufo115.com/evidence-timeline/incidents/majestic-12-1984.

Last reviewed by The UFO115 desk. Record UFO115-INC-1984-001, version 1. Machine-readable record.

“THE FILE THEY CLOSED” is UFO115's editorial framing, not a claim that events happened as dramatized.