Black Friday: S4 Declassification opens Nov 27, 2:14 AM ET

UFO115
Sign in Cartitems: 0
A dusk canyon in the New Mexico high desert with a wide, pale disc resting on the floor and two small distant figures looking on. AI-generated.

WHAT DID THEY FIND?

The Aztec UFO Incident — 1948

Sixteen bodies, a saucer, and a con that ended in a fraud conviction.

UFO115-INC-1948-001March 1948Hart Canyon, about 12 miles northeast of Aztec, New Mexico, United StatesDisputed

AI-generated artistic reconstruction. UFO115 dramatization, not evidence and not a photograph of the event.

According to Frank Scully, an unidentified craft carrying sixteen humanoid bodies made a controlled landing in Hart Canyon, New Mexico, in March 1948 and was recovered by the military [1]. The story reached the public through Scully's 1949 Variety columns and his 1950 book Behind the Flying Saucers, based on what two men told him [1]. In 1952 the story was exposed as a hoax made up by two con men as part of a scheme to sell materials said to contain extraterrestrial technology, and the two men were convicted of fraud in 1953 [1][2]. Some ufologists say a one-page 1950 FBI memo backs up the crash, but the FBI called it a second- or third-hand claim it never investigated [1].

WHAT KIND OF CLAIM IS THIS?

  • 2 DOCUMENTEDEstablished by records or contemporary reporting.
  • 2 OFFICIALWhat an official body stated or concluded.
  • 1 WITNESSWhat a witness reported. Not independently established.
  • 2 DISPUTEDContested between sources.
  • 2 ALLEGEDA claim made later, unsupported by the record.
  1. DOCUMENTED Newton and Gebauer were convicted of fraud in 1953 over a scheme to sell materials said to incorporate extraterrestrial technology. [1][2][3]
  2. DOCUMENTED A metal sample given to J. P. Cahn by Newton and Gebauer turned out to be ordinary aluminium. [1][2][3]
  3. OFFICIAL The FBI stated in 2013 that the Hottel memo does not prove the existence of UFOs and is a second- or third-hand claim it never investigated. [1]
  4. OFFICIAL The Air Force said there is no Hangar 18 at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base and noted that Robert Spencer Carr's 1974 claims mirrored the plot of a novel. [1]
  5. ALLEGED Scully's account said a 99-foot craft carrying sixteen humanoid bodies landed in Hart Canyon in March 1948 and was taken by the military. [1]
  6. WITNESS The Aztec county sheriff and newspaper editor of March 1948, the sheriff's son and the landowning family all denied that a retrieval took place. [1]
  7. DISPUTED The Ramseys and Frank Thayer argue the crash was real and that the government engineered the case against Newton and Gebauer to sink Aztec. [1][4]
  8. DISPUTED The Hottel memo may relate to Aztec, but it never names the town and the original source of the informant's account is unknown. [1][4]
  9. ALLEGED In 1974 ufologist Robert Spencer Carr claimed that alien bodies recovered near Aztec were stored at a Wright-Patterson building called Hangar 18. [1]

WHAT HAPPENED

The Aztec account says that in March 1948 an unidentified aerial craft made a controlled landing in Hart Canyon, 12 miles (19 km) northeast of Aztec, New Mexico, and that the military recovered it together with sixteen humanoid bodies [1]. The craft was said to be 99 feet (30 m) in diameter [1]. Frank Scully, a journalist, published the story in Variety columns in 1949 and expanded it into the 1950 book Behind the Flying Saucers [1]. The account reached him from two men named as Silas Newton and Leo Gebauer [1].

In Scully's telling the incident had been covered up and the military had taken the craft for secret research [1]. He wrote that it came from Venus and worked on "magnetic principles", and that its inhabitants carried concentrated food wafers and "heavy water" [1]. No contemporary press accounts of a crash or a recovery have been found [1]. Local newspaper accounts show nothing for the relevant dates [3]. In 1952 the story was exposed as a hoax, and Newton and Gebauer were convicted of fraud in 1953 [1].

Newton and Gebauer were convicted of fraud in 1953 over a scheme to sell materials said to incorporate extraterrestrial technology.

BACKGROUND

In the late 1940s and early 1950s Newton and Gebauer travelled through Aztec trying to sell devices known in the oil business as doodlebugs [1]. They said the devices could find oil, gas and gold, and that they worked because they were based on alien technology recovered from a crashed flying saucer [1]. According to Karl Pflock, quoted by IBTimes, what set their pitch apart from earlier cons was the claim that their doodlebugs were better because they drew on alien technology [3]. The Skeptic's Dictionary says the pair were involved in oil-exploration finance schemes and that the hoax was meant to attract investors [2].

Scully's book became a best-seller and influenced public perceptions of UFOs [1]. The science writer Martin Gardner criticised the story as full of "wild imaginings" and "scientific howlers" [1]. Donald Keyhoe, a pioneering ufologist known for backing UFO claims, regarded Scully's narrative as "absurd and fanciful" [1]. From the mid-1950s to the early 1970s most ufologists considered the Aztec crash thoroughly discredited and avoided the subject [1].

CHRONOLOGY

  1. The date given in the Scully account for the alleged landing in Hart Canyon, 12 miles northeast of Aztec [1]. [1]

  2. Frank Scully publishes the story in a series of Variety columns [1]. [1]

  3. The Wyandotte Echo prints a version of the story that was traced thirdhand to Newton [1][3]. [1][3]

  4. FBI agent Guy Hottel writes the one-page memo relaying a third party's account of recovered craft [1][4]. [1][4]

  5. Scully's book Behind the Flying Saucers is published [1]. [1]

  6. J. P. Cahn exposes the hoax in True magazine [1][2]. [1][2]

  7. Newton and Gebauer are convicted of fraud [1][2]. [1][2]

  8. Robert Spencer Carr claims Aztec bodies are stored at Hangar 18; the Air Force denies it [1]. [1]

  9. William Steinman and Wendelle Stevens publish UFO Crash at Aztec [2][3]. [2][3]

  10. The Black Vault obtains an unredacted Hottel memo naming the informant as Karl Howe [1]. [1]

WITNESS ACCOUNTS

The Aztec story has no independent eyewitnesses on record [2][3]. Skeptic's Dictionary notes that no one in the area noticed the crash or any military activity, which left Newton and Gebauer free to play wildly with the truth [2]. IBTimes likewise says there were no other witnesses [3]. So the account rests on what Newton and Gebauer told Scully [1]. Scully also relied on a group of scientists he called Dr. G and never revealed who they were [4].

The people of Aztec have been recorded as rejecting it. The writer Jerome Clark states that residents have "with virtually one voice" denied that any UFO retrieval happened there on any date, and that they learned of the story only through Scully's publicity [1]. Those who denied it include the local newspaper editor and the county sheriff in March 1948, the sheriff's son, and the family who owned the land [1]. Against this, Scott and Suzanne Ramsey, who have spent more than 30 years researching the event, and their co-author Frank Thayer say the incident is well documented [4]. Those claims are theirs and are contested [1][4].

A lone walker on a dirt trail through desert scrub below a mesa at dusk near Aztec, New Mexico
AI RECONSTRUCTIONA dirt trail through desert scrub below a mesa at dusk, the kind of ground visitors cross when searching for the reported crash site near Aztec. AI reconstruction. AI-generated artistic reconstruction. UFO115 dramatization, not evidence and not a photograph of the event.

#NOMORESECRETS

WEAR THE STORY.

The full collection

WHAT THE INVESTIGATIONS FOUND

The hoax was exposed by J. P. Cahn of the San Francisco Chronicle. He asked Newton and Gebauer for a piece of the supposed alien metal, and the sample they gave him turned out to be aluminium [1][3]. Cahn published his account in True magazine in 1952 [1][2]. Other people who had been swindled then came forward, among them a Denver millionaire who pressed charges, and the two men were convicted of fraud in 1953 [1][2][3]. Skeptic's Dictionary reports they charged $18,500 for a "tuner" that could be bought at surplus stores for $3.50 at the time [2]. When Newton died in 1972 he faced 40 legal claims over alleged oil and gas schemes [1].

A separate document trail concerns an FBI memo dated 22 March 1950, written by Guy Hottel, special agent in charge of the Washington Field Office [1][4]. It relays a third party's account that an Air Force investigator had reported three circular craft about 50 feet across, each holding three small humanoid bodies, recovered in New Mexico [1]. It ends: "No further evaluation was attempted" [1]. In 2013 the FBI said the memo does not prove the existence of UFOs and called it a second- or third-hand claim it never investigated [1].

EXPLANATIONS

The documented explanation is fraud. Several sources record the aluminium sample, the convictions and the sale of oil-finding devices presented as alien technology [1][2][3]. IBTimes adds that the FBI held documents showing it knew about both Newton and Gebauer, and that mining frauds were common in the south-west at the time [3].

For the Hottel memo, researchers trace a chain of retelling back to Newton. Skeptic's Dictionary and IBTimes describe the story passing from Newton to George Koehler and on through several people to a used car dealer, Rudy Fick. From Fick it reached the Wyandotte Echo of Kansas City, Kansas, in January 1950, where an Air Force investigator read it and passed it to Hottel [2][3]. Wikipedia reports that the Ramseys, Thayer and David E. Thomas link the memo to Aztec because it resembles Newton's claims more than accounts of Roswell [1]. IBTimes argues that an alien craft disabled by high-powered radar is implausible, since ordinary aircraft fly through radar without incident [3]. A common criticism of these theories is that the memo never mentions Aztec [1][4].

WHAT REMAINS DISPUTED

Some researchers reject the hoax verdict. The Ramseys and Thayer argue that the crash was real and that the Newton and Gebauer trial was "engineered... to sink Aztec" [1][4]. Thayer says the government "engineered that story to sink Aztec" [4]. Clark, however, criticises Scott Ramsey for calling Newton a "man of science" without basis and for ignoring evidence that does not support his hypothesis [1]. The researchers also cite an FBI report of a sting in Denver, run with the Army Counterintelligence Division, against a man selling pictures said to show the Aztec flying saucer. They take this as evidence that the government treated the saucer seriously [4]. That interpretation is theirs and is not independently confirmed in these sources [4].

The source of the Hottel memo is only partly resolved. In August 2022 The Black Vault obtained an unredacted copy naming the informant as Karl Howe of the Metropolitan Police Department [1]. Neither the memo nor supporting documents show where Howe got the information, so the narrative cannot be conclusively tied to Newton [1]. Parts of the Aztec story, such as recovered alien bodies and a saucer-shaped craft of seemingly indestructible metal, have become mixed into accounts of the Roswell incident [1].

QUESTIONS PEOPLE ASK

Did a flying saucer crash at Aztec, New Mexico, in 1948?

No contemporary press accounts of a crash have been found, and Aztec residents have denied that a retrieval happened [1]. The story came from Newton and Gebauer, who were convicted of fraud in 1953 [1][2]. Some researchers, including the Ramseys and Thayer, argue it was real [4].

Who were Silas Newton and Leo Gebauer?

They were two men who travelled through Aztec trying to sell doodlebugs, devices they claimed could find oil, gas and gold using alien technology [1]. They were convicted of fraud in 1953 [1][2].

What is the Hottel memo?

It is a one-page FBI memorandum dated 22 March 1950 that relays a third party's claim about three recovered craft in New Mexico, each holding three small bodies [1]. The FBI said it does not prove the existence of UFOs and was a second- or third-hand claim it never investigated [1].

Does the Hottel memo mention Aztec?

No. Scott Ramsey acknowledges the memo does not mention Aztec, and Wikipedia notes it is ambiguous about the crash location [1][4].

How was the Aztec story exposed?

J. P. Cahn of the San Francisco Chronicle obtained a sample of the supposed alien metal, which proved to be aluminium, and reported it in True magazine in 1952 [1][2][3].

Why is it called the other Roswell?

Wikipedia records that the case is sometimes called the "other Roswell" but does not explain the nickname [1]. Parts of the Aztec story, such as recovered alien bodies and a craft of seemingly indestructible metal, have become intertwined with accounts of the Roswell incident [1].

THE RECONSTRUCTION

A dusk canyon in the New Mexico high desert with a wide, pale disc resting on the floor and two small distant figures looking on. AI-generated.
AI RECONSTRUCTIONAI-generated artistic reconstruction. UFO115 dramatization, not evidence and not a photograph of the event.

A dusk canyon in the New Mexico high desert with a wide, pale disc resting on the floor and two small distant figures looking on. It shows the scene as the Scully story described it, not anything documented to have been there.

AI-generated artistic reconstruction. UFO115 dramatization, not evidence and not a photograph of the event. Hero image source: UFO115 reconstruction (local AI model, 2026).

SOURCES

  1. Aztec crashed saucer hoax. Wikipedia, read 2026-11-15. Read 2026-11-15. Link checked 2026-11-15 (HTTP 200).
  2. Aztec (New Mexico) UFO Hoax - The Skeptic's Dictionary. skepdic.com, read 2026-11-15. Read 2026-11-15. Link checked 2026-11-15 (HTTP 200).
  3. FBI Hottel Memo Reveals UFO Hoax. ibtimes.com, read 2026-11-15. Read 2026-11-15. Link checked 2026-11-15 (HTTP 200).
  4. Uncovering The Aztec UFO Incident. DGO Magazine, 2023-06-01. Read 2026-11-15. Link checked 2026-11-15 (HTTP 200).

CITE THIS RECORD

UFO115. "The Aztec UFO Incident — 1948." UFO115 Evidence Timeline, record UFO115-INC-1948-001, version 1. Last reviewed 2026-11-15. https://ufo115.com/evidence-timeline/incidents/aztec-1948

APA: UFO115. (2026). The Aztec UFO Incident — 1948 (Record UFO115-INC-1948-001, v1). UFO115 Evidence Timeline. https://ufo115.com/evidence-timeline/incidents/aztec-1948

MLA: "The Aztec UFO Incident — 1948." UFO115 Evidence Timeline, UFO115, 2026-11-15, https://ufo115.com/evidence-timeline/incidents/aztec-1948.

Last reviewed by The UFO115 desk. Record UFO115-INC-1948-001, version 1. Machine-readable record.

“WHAT DID THEY FIND?” is UFO115's editorial framing, not a claim that events happened as dramatized.